When can you skip facing the Kaaba?
Conditions of Salah: Facing the Kaaba and Permissible Exceptions
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour continues his discussion on the conditions of salah, specifically focusing on the fifth condition of facing the Kaaba. He explains the principal rule: if the Kaaba is visible, one must face it directly; if not visible, one must face its general direction with a permissible deviation of up to 45 degrees. Sh. Ali Mashhour then details three exceptions where facing the Kaaba is no longer obligatory: when a person has no way of knowing its direction, during fear prayer when life is at stake, and when praying optional prayers while traveling. He clarifies the common misconception that travelers can pray obligatory prayers in any direction, emphasizing that only optional prayers have this allowance. Using Quranic verses and hadith from the Prophet (peace be upon him) and the companion Omar, Sh. Ali Mashhour establishes that whoever makes a genuine effort to face the Kaaba according to their knowledge and ability will have their prayer accepted, even if they later discover they faced the wrong direction.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
Alhamdulillah. Continuing.
[Silence]
Where we left off yesterday in the conditions of and we had arrived at the fifth Fifth condition which is facing the based on all of the discussions we had before a very well-known and well researched a very well-known and wellressearched and commonplace principle amongst the jurists of Islam. becomes clear to us. And this principle is as follows.
[Silence]
They say that if a person can see thea, it is thus obligatory upon him to face the physical structure itself. If it is in sight, you must be facing directly at it. If you are off left or right, prayer is invalid. However, if the ka is not visible to you, then you need to face its general direction. And as we mentioned before, the general direction is very there's a very big grace leniency in the direction of the Cabba. 20° off, 15° off, 25 degrees off. These will not affect a person's prayer. Our prophet sallall.aii wasallam says in he says He says between the east and the west is a direction for salah. This is for the people in Medina. Correct? Between the east and west is a direction for salah. That is the direction of prayer. Between the east and west, very broad, very open. So the the the rule is if you can see the Kaa you must face it directly. You must face the actual building. However, if you are out of sight of the Kaa you must face its direction. You must face its general direction. And we said the absolute maximum a person can be turned away from the cabba for their prayer to be invalid is how many degrees? 45 degrees. Very good. That's this. So basically you are or this. All right. Somebody's going to take a screenshot and say that she Ali is affiliated with Nazi Germany. The this this direction or this direction. This is 45° right? So you are completely turned away from it. This is beyond the grace the allowable amount but now there are a few exceptions to this. There are a few exceptions to this. Namely there are three exceptions. When a person is not where where a condition of salah where facing the no longer is a is a condition of salah. Three scenarios, three instances. Number one, a person has no way of knowing where it is. Let's say they're in a prison somewhere. Let's say they are in a place where they've never been and they have no way of knowing which direction the is. That's clear because of course all commandments of Islam are based and built upon what? Ability. Number two, in an instant of when a person is praying a prayer of fear, fear prayer, whether this is in war or outside of war, a person must face away from the in order to guard a particular direction or watch a particular direction. Their life is at stake in this instance. a person does not have to face the number three. Now listen closely because this is the most misunderstood of the three. The third scenario is that a person is praying an optional prayer in travel. Now notice the two it has to be an optional prayer. Many people have heard that when a person is traveling they do not have to face the that's only half of it and so many people believe that if they are traveling they can face away from the and making the obligatory prayer and that they can pray the obligatory prayer sitting down or riding even though they can stand if they wanted. This is incorrect according to the consensus of the scholars of Islam. This is amongst all the jurists of Islam, all of the this is only number one a person is traveling and whilst the traveler he is praying what? An optional prayer. an optional prayer, not an obligatory prayer. Any obligatory prayer must be prayed towards the in its entirety unless one of the previous two is mentioned is occurring which is fear and right a person doesn't know which direction the is or is unable to face the for whatever reason correct so it's three exceptions number one, right? Inability. Let's say inability either because they don't have the knowledge of where the is or they don't have the ability. Number two, right? Number three, optional prayer in travel. Not just travel by itself and not just optional by itself. It has to be both happening simultaneously. Optional prayer in travel. And this is what the author now tells us. He says, Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala says in verse 239 of "And if you are in a state of fear then pray while you are walking or while you are riding." This verse was explained by Omar whether you are facing the or not meaning under this under the instance of fearb's student.
[Silence]
Tells us that Omar only mentioned that because he had heard it from the prophet sallall.aii wasallam.
[Silence]
The Muslim. He says, "And Omar narrated that the messenger of Allah sallall.aii wasallam used to make his optional prayers on his riding animal in any direction he would be traveling and he would make the walah upon it." Except the only exception is when he would pray obligatory prayer. Then he would face the right. Then he would face the.
[Silence]
Foreign.
[Silence]
One last final point and that is that whoever tries to face the to the best of his ability and to the best of his knowledge and then later finds out that they actually prayed to the incorrect direction then their prayer is accepted. He then cites a narration on the authority of who narrates that we were with the prophet sallall.aii wasallam on a very dark night during a travel during a journey. And so it was so dark meaning that the sky was overcast. They couldn't see the stars. It was so dark that we could not figure out which direction thela was. And so each of us used his best judgment and prayed in a particular direction. And so when we when the morning came the next day, we mentioned this to the messenger of Allah sall.ai alaihi wasallam and Allah responded by sending down the verse and to Allah belongs the east and the west and whichever direction you were to face then that is the direction of Allah. This is verse number 115 of Bakar which we discussed previously. So these are the exceptions of facing the outside of these exceptions a person must remake the prayer. Let's say a person goes to a city, a town in our time and, you know, tries a little bit, asks the the clerk at the gas station or, you know, makes a kind of half-hearted effort to face the and then makes salah and finds out that he made salah in the wrong direction. Does he have to make up the prayer? What do you think? Because because he could be certain of the direction of he's in a city in our time, right? He could have been more diligent, right? However, if the person were to do everything in his power and he's unable, he's does not find the direction of the in this case, he does not make the salah over. But if he does a half-hearted effort, finds out it's wrong, and he knows that he could have done better, then he makes up the prayer. Even if it's after 10 days, even if it's after 10 years. Now,.
[Silence]
Using the GPS would be okay.
[Arabic recitation]