MCC Tucson Lectures
Muslim Community Center of Tucson
←This Week
October 18, 2026·Jumada I 7, 1448 AH·5:59 AM·14m·Sunday-Fajr

When Should We Say Prayer is Better Than Sleep?

The Correct Timing of Tawheed in the Fajr Adhan: First or Second Call

adhanfajrtawheedislamic jurisprudenceprophet's sunnahfiqh differencesmadhabsmadinah
▶ Watch on YouTube
✦

Summary

Sh. Ali Mashhour discusses the issue of when Tawheed (the phrase 'prayer is better than sleep') should be recited during the Fajr Adhan. He explains the historical context of the two Adhans in Medina during the Prophet's time - the first Adhan by Bilal before dawn as a service to the community, and the second by Ibn Umm Maktum at actual dawn when prayer becomes obligatory. Sh. Ali Mashhour clarifies that the Tawheed belongs in the first Adhan because its purpose is to wake people from sleep, while the second Adhan's function is to announce the actual time of prayer. He presents evidence from Islamic jurisprudence, including statements from Ibn Al-Qayyim and the companion Umar, establishing that Tawheed is part of the first Adhan.

Transcript

Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.

Alhamdulillah.

[Silence]

So this morning we have arrived at a part regarding which is referred to as that a person says in the adan after that a person says India then after he says twice. Now this tethweep it is an issue where is this meaning an issue of contention difference of opinion amongst the scholarship of Islam is this in the first adan or second. So in order to understand this, we started discussing yesterday the way that the adan was made in the prophet sallallah.aii wasallam's time and in Medina specifically. So in Medina there are two number one is and the second is who was a blind man. And so Bil would make the first aden for fud. And then Maktum would make the second adan which was the adan for the time of salah. Meaning the dawn is now here. This is when you can actually make fudg. The first adan is a service. It's a service to the neighborhood. It's a service to the Muslim in the vicinity of the masid to help them kind of gauge how close we are to fud to help them kind of gauge when it is that we have to start getting ready for start getting ready for if we are fasting when we are to start having our breakfast ending our breakfast etc. This is the point of this adan. Based on that, if there is a need for a second adan, then the adan, the second adan should be made. for instance, if there's a a masid in a neighborhood that depends on that adan or that it helps them wake up, etc., then they make the second adan. If not then one adan for fud is what is obligatory right and it's a little bit similar to the second adan for jum and this is one of the way places that extrapolated this ruling from from adan and there being two adan similarly there being two adan for J and it will always be that if there's a need for this second adan for then it is made just if there is a need for the second adan for jum then it is made if there is no need for it then there doesn't have to be a second ad then for jy there doesn't have to be a second adan for fud now which one of these two aden 10. So we have basically three. We have the one that is before the break of dawn that is bil then we have that is the actual break of dawn and then we have the right. The question is which one of those two did? Was it or was it? And why this is important? Because if we don't need to have a second for and we only have one then that means that then for if we say that was done by that means that if we only have one we don't even say if we just do one aden if we say that it was that said then this means whether there is one or two adan we always say it's in the adan of this is the difference of opinion and one of the reasons why there is even a difference of opinion is because in the language of the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam the Wordan is used to describe the adan and is used to describe the too. So when the narrator says in the aden which one is this? Is this the when he says the first aden does that mean the the aden the first aden compared to the or does that mean the first ad then compared to the actual of this is where the difference of opinion comes into play. The author says,.

[Silence]

And so when the prophet Sam taught and his name is when he taught when he taught him the adan, he taught him to say in the first of after say in the first adan of morning and then continue Allah abbar Allah abbar Abu Mah was his muadin where in Mecca very good here the author has a statement from his very famous book to death Baby,.

[Silence]

So here he mentions a nar a statement from taken from his bookam is a well-known explanation of his on the book of Hul, he mentions that says and so the legislation or the act of having a this is to be done in the first for and this makes sense. He says because that first is when people are waking up right well we're not sleeping so why do we need to hear that right the first is when people are sleeping and they're being told salah is better than sleep right is better than sleep we're sleeping is better than sleep we wake But if it's in the second ad then is better than sleep. You already woke us up in the first. We're not sleeping anymore. Correct? He says, "And so it is in the first of because it is designed to help people wake up from sleep." And so it becomes appropriate to say no. And as for the second adan, the adan of ibmi, right? As for the second adan, it is its function primarily is to inform everyone and to announce the time of salah is in. And so it is a call to actual prayer, not just the waking up. And this is why it doesn't have that distinction from the rest of the fivean of the rest of the week. Abdah and his he has a narration that is authentic that Abdullahbar said, "Theweome in the time of the prophet Sam was in the first of the two of them." So this companion identifies it for us. He says in the first of the two aden. Now remember what we said about being called aden. Right? And there could be some kind of a mixup there. You can say, well, maybe what Omar meant was the first meaning of the the first compared to the the being the second. We say this is not possible. Why? Because no one says or claims that is done during That's not even part of the debate, right? So because of that we have the first the second that's number one and number two Omar identifies it as being where in number one now having said this it's a difference of opinion amongst the scholars of the form in the med famously it is in the actual for If you were to go to Mecca, you'll hear it during that then. Is this a huge big issue? No. Because this is it's but if we were to identify it, practice it ourselves, this is the closer of the two opinions. Alhamdulillah.