How did the Prophet truly raise his hands?
The Prophet's Method of Prayer: Hand Positions and Takbir in Salah
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour continues his detailed analysis of the Prophet Muhammad's (peace be upon him) description of prayer, focusing on the physical positions and movements during salah. He explains how the Prophet would raise his hands with takbir, detailing the variations in height (shoulder or ear level) and timing (before, during, or after saying Allahu Akbar), all of which are considered authentic. The lecture then covers the placement of the right hand over the left hand, discussing the various narrations about hand positioning on the body (chest, navel, or below) and concluding that while all these positions have weak individual chains of narration, they collectively demonstrate that multiple positions were practiced, making them all acceptable.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
[Arabic recitation]
[Silence]
So we are continuing in the beginnings of the chapter regarding the description of the prophet sallall.aii wasallam's prayer. Now he prayed for 23 years as the companions watched and there are many variations to his prayers. Things that he would do sometimes that he wouldn't do others. things that he would do in a certain way and do it in another way in other instances. We will mention all of those things inshallah but the general way that he would pray is as follows. He would stand for salah and he would say Allahbar. He would start his salah with Allahbar and he would raise his hands with the so when he would raise his hands he would raise his hands with the Allahbar. Now, we'll get into this part in a later chapter that is specific to this, but suffices us to know here that when he would raise his hands, his hands the his palms would face the this. Many people know that he would raise his hands when he makes. As a matter of fact, you'd be hardressed to see someone make salah without raising his hands for at least the first. However, that's as far as most people's knowledge goes. How did he raise his hands exactly? There is no narration of him raising his hands this, of him actually touching his chest or ears. There's no narration of him raising his hands in any way except this. And he would raise his hands with his palms facing the and that's the general rule. Everything that can be faced towards the is faced towards the inah. So he would raise his hands this. Now his palms, his fingers would be neither opened this nor would they be cuffed this or together. They would just be this normal. He would raise his hands sometimes shoulder height just in sujud. exactly the same as sujud. It would either be sometimes shoulder height and sometimes ear height, the bottoms of the ears this. Both are correct. And he would raise them just like this. He wouldn't touch them to his shoulders or his ears. He would just raise them to that height. So he would raise them sometimes to his shoulder height, sometimes to the height of his ears. And with the first, which is referred to as right, he would sometimes raise his hands before he would say Allahbar, sometimes during and sometimes after. All are narrated, all are authentic. So he would say Allahbar that or Allahbar or Allahbar all are correct, right? But when he would raise his hands and this is how he would raise his hands throughout prayer. Anytime you read that he raised his hands be be at before rur after rur right this is the way that it would be hands facing towards the shoulder height or ear height now sometimes it becomes difficult to do these things exactly this in jama right because there's people next to you And a person can do of this as much as he can without impinging on the person or persons next to him. He says and then he would place his right hand on his left hand. Here in the book it says on his chest. We have two types of narrations regarding where he would place his hands. One narration is in a sunn. One narration is in Bkari that the prophet sallall.aii wasallam would place his right hand over his left hand. That much is agreed upon amongst all the companions. And not just amongst all the companions but amongst all of the prophets. The prophet sallallah.aii wasallam mentions in one narration in the sun that we the prophets have been commanded to place our right hand over our left hands in salah. So the right hand over the left hand in salah. Now then we have a second set of narrations. These narrations describe where on his body the placement of his hands would be. Some narrations say his chest. And when we say chest in Arabic, the chest is all the way to the sternum. It's not necessarily up here. This is called a nah. This is the chest here, right? And so on the chest would look this. And not necessarily this. Look this. Some would say over his navl. Some would say below his navl. All of the narrations, listen closely, all of the narrations regarding where he would place his hands about his body, all of them are weak. All of them. None of them is fully authentic on its own. They're all weak. They all have weakness in their chains of narration. And this tells us a couple of things. One of the things it tells us is that there were different places that he would place his hands on different occasions. And we have narrations from the companions that they would sometimes place their hands over their navl, sometimes on their naval, sometimes below their navl, sometimes just under their chest, on their sternum, etc. All of this is correct because when we look at alkari in his he could have chosen one of these but he didn't he didn't choose any of them the only thing alkari mentions in his placing the right hand over the left handd that's it that's all he mentioned he doesn't mention anything else and why is that for these reasons that I've just mentioned. All of it is acceptable. All of it is correct. Inshallah. However, the way that he would place his hands is sometimes he would grasp he would grasp his wrist this and sometimes he would place. However, hand overhand this. No, he would not do this. This is not something that the prophet sallallah.aii wasallam did. It would always be over the hand and wrist like this. Right? So he is making salah Allahbar right hand over the left hand. Sometimes he would grasp his wrist this and sometimes he would place just this. Both are authentic. Both are narrated from the prophet sallall.aii Wasam, right? And when he would place his hands, they would be placed anywhere below the navl, on the navl, above the navl, on the stomach, on the sternum. All of it is correct. And when we look at the mahib, the different med make a choice because the exact purpose of a med is to choose one from the many options. It doesn't mean the rest are wrong. It just means that this me chooses this. So he went for the most natural the most natural position of the body, right? He he knows the narrations are inauthentic. So he went for the most natural position on the body which is between the navl and the chest. So in avaf and the it is on or about the naval area or just below. Right? In another narration from Imam Ahmed himself on the chest here, all of this is acceptable. There's no problem with any of these. Now, there is one opinion in the Malik that he would leave his hands to the side. This is not from Imam Malik himself ever. Imam Malik himself never chose this. It was always right hand over the left hand. Some later Malikia had chosen that but it is much weaker and contradicting to known authentic narrations of the prophet sallall.aii wasallam. And any exceptions to that were due to outside circumstances one time he fell off of a horse and he hurt his hand sallallahu alaihi wasallam and so he left his hands to his sides. We learn from this that putting the right hand on the left hand in salah is it's not a pillar of salah. It's not an obligation of salah. But if you are to do it, which everyone should, and it is a very strong sunnah, then the right hand goes on the left hand. However about a person goes to doing this, we will take a stop there. Inshallah, we'll pick this up again tomorrow.
[Arabic recitation]