Why Your Masjid's Qibla Direction Doesn't Need to Be Perfect
Understanding the Qibla Direction in Prayer: Approximation vs. Precision
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour continues his discussion on the conditions of salah, specifically focusing on the fifth condition regarding the direction toward the Kaaba (Qibla). He explains the scholarly differences in interpreting what 'direction' means—some scholars requiring exact precision while the majority understanding it as approximate direction. Sh. Ali Mashhour clarifies that approximately 45 degrees off in either direction is acceptable, and shares his experience with Muslims who obsess over minor directional discrepancies in masjids. He uses Quranic and prophetic narrations to demonstrate that the Prophet (peace be upon him) taught companions approximate directions (east-west guidelines) rather than precise calculations, emphasizing that Islam is a religion accessible to all people regardless of their mathematical or astronomical knowledge.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
Alhamdulillah.
[Silence]
Continuing in the conditions of salah. Yesterday we began discussing the fifth condition mentioned in the book here which is And we mention that a lot of the difference of opinion with respect to how precise a person's direction and salah is with resp to in accordance to the is really hinging on the definition of one word and that is the word. Some of the scholars like view the word in this context to mean exact and utter center which means that a person must use all means possible to direct himself as closely to the the as possible. Whereas the majority of the scholars and jurists of Islam and companions of the prophet sallall.aii including but not limited to understand this word to mean the approximate direction of the approximate direction of the and if we were to quantify this what is the general rule how many degrees is a person approximately ly directed towards the we mentioned yesterday. I had gotten confused half of a 90° angle. The scholars say what is half of a 90° angle 45° which is essentially this. If a person is if the is this way and they are this way they are completely faced away from the now. Now the is to their right or the is to their left in this case. This is too far. Anything within that is acceptable and is how the companions and would pray. I will tell you something. This issue of direction of the is a source of whis for many Muslim. I have never exceeding this masid. This is the first masid and I'm still waiting for him to come. Every single masid I have served at, taught at, worked at, whatever throughout the years, for the past two and a half decades. Unfailingly, someone will come in to see me. They need to see the email. They've got a folder with them with much research and they'll sit me down and they'll explain to me how the masid is slightly off from the direction of the every single time I go to every masid there is always this guy he comes up it's not the same guy but he has the same spirit right and he will come in with all this research and he'll sit me down for a half an hour and he'll explain to me Now this masid is actually not directly towards the and it is 15° or it is 10° off or it is 13° or it is 20° or it is 18° off of the and this guy never has any proposed solutions. He only presents problems. If you ask okay so what shall we do about this? The answer is always I don't know. you're the imam and I'm I've done my part of telling you you know and that's why I don't pray in this masid. I have I have seen it everywhere I go. This is very incorrect way of understanding this ruling of Islam. We if we were to really go based on this 90% or maybe 95% of all mass it built before the last 50 years are going to be slightly off from the direction of the this is something which is common and that's okay because the prophet sallall.aii alaihi wasallam never commanded his companions to find and calculate exactly the degree and direction of the and if a person is slightly to the right or slightly to the left this will not harm anything let me ask you a question let's say we are making a row to make the direction of the we'd have to see how exactly wide. The is the ka exactly. And our row could not be any wider than the exact width of the cabba. If it were one man wider than the direction than the width of the cabba, one person is invariably missing. This is not a practice in ballistics. Well, you know, if we were to do that, we might as well we might as well work curvature into our rows, right? We might as well calculate for the corololis effect and the movement. We might as well calculate gravity and wind and trajectory so we can get proper ballistics. Now we need a military ballistician to come and tell us which is the direction of the this is not what is intended and as we'll see from the narrations the direction of the that the companions prayed was always an approximation an approximation both the way that they did it and the way that the commands of the prophet sallall.aii alaihi wasallam came. It's not a misunderstanding of physics, direction or geometry that gets a lot of people. It's a misunderstanding of the command of the Quran and Sunnah that gets a lot of people. that the prophet Sam said he says to the man who was making a mistake in his salah. If you stand or wish to make salah then fully make wudoo and then face the now the prophet sallall.ai am he had said to the companions that when you go to make salah now if we imagine he's telling this to his companions and they are in Medina where is Medina with respect to Mecca which direction is the to them it would be south roughly a little bit southeast right be a little bit southeast but it's essentially south now what does the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam tell them he says he says in one narration with respect to relieving oneself because when a person relieves himself he is not to face the we We already discussed this in earlier chapters. So he says, listen to this narration. He says, "Do not face the when you are relieving yourselves, whether urinating or defecating. rather face to the east or to the west, the east or to the west. Not so when a person is facing completely to the east or to the west, they are away from the regardless of if they are exactly east or west. They could be they could be slightly northwest which will face them somewhat towards the direction of the or vice versa. This is not a priority. And another narration the prophet sallall.aii alaihi wasallam says, he says, "If the if the west is to your right and the east is to your left, then this is the notice the wording." Now, this is specific to who? To him and those who are in Medina with him, right? He says, "If the west is to your right, where the sun sets, and the sun rises to your left, you're going to be facing where? South and south is the direction of who? People who are in Medina. Now the sun changes where it rises and sets from, right? It pivots. It moves. If you always follow this rule, there's going to be a point where you are going to be facing to the east of the or facing to the west of the not specifically, not precisely. He didn't teach them calculations of the of the stars and calculations. Gibl did not come to them every time they were traveling and making salah to direct them towards the the prophet Sam gave approximations. He said, he says, "We are fundamentally an illiterate friendly nation, a nation that is illiterate." It doesn't mean we're all illiterate. It means we do not need to be literate in order to worship Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala and fulfill our religion. All of the rulings of our religion can be learned by the literate and the illiterate. All of the how to make salah, how to make give zak, how to figure out the direction of the this can all be figured out by both layman and expert both genius and fool. Every single person can participate in the general rulings of Islam. Anytime we have calculations and sure if you're going to build a masid that's okay to make these calculations but the masid does not have to be exactly exactly laser direction of the and most massagid are not and the companions understood this and they prayed in every masid that they came across. They prayed in every masjid that they came across. And the prophet sallall.aii wasallam gave them the general direction. Put the west to your right or the sunset to your right and the sunrise to your left and pray. And he said, he said, "What is between the east and the west is the direction of imagine how general that is because again Medina is not due north of Mecca. It is slightly to the west of Mecca, right? It is slightly to the west of Mecca. Mecca is slightly to the east of Medina. However, he taught his companions what is between what is between andith he taught them what is between the east and the west is a direction of salah. Right? And Allah Subhanahu Waaala says in he says and to Allah belong the east and the west. So whichever direction you face then that then that is the direction of Allah meaning the direction of the this narration this verse was revealed regarding making salah in tra in travel on a person's animal whichever direction it faces and it was revealed with respect to those who make a mistake and pray slightly off of the Allah says Allah to him belongs the east and the west and so whichever direction you face that is a direction that belongs to Allah subhanahu waala.
[Silence]
Also I'm thinking.