What Must Be Covered in Prayer?
Islamic Rules of Modesty (Awrah) in Prayer and Worship
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour provides a detailed Islamic jurisprudential analysis of the rules of covering (awrah) for both men and women during prayer and other Islamic activities. He explains that a man's awrah extends from the navel to below the knees, including both shoulders, while a woman must cover her entire body except for her face and hands during prayer. Sh. Ali Mashhour references scholarly consensus and specific narrations from the Prophet's companions, particularly addressing the difference between covering requirements in private prayer versus public settings like Tawaf around the Kaaba. He discusses the conditions for proper covering, including that garments must not be transparent and must not reveal skin color underneath.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
Alhamdulillah.
[Silence]
So, thus far we have taken the the outline of the male or a man's insah and we mentioned that a man's insah consists of that which is between the naval and the knees and two the two shoulders some scholars mention one shoulder the correct and safer is two shoulders the author mentions a number of narrations with respect to this most of which we have read. However, this is the the outcome of the author's listings here and his sightings. The next is the of the female insah. A woman's a where is it? And what must she cover in her prayer in order for her prayer to be considered valid?
[Silence]
He says, The entire body of the woman, the female in prayer is considered the necessary a to be covered except for the face and the two hands. So the two hands from the wrist and the face. Now notice that the wording here includes the feet. This includes the feet and this is the author is mentioning here essentially the fatwa of salam's wife was asked what a woman should wear in her salah and she said that she is to wear that covers the shoulders and to wear a dress a d which covers the feet. She specifically mentions the feet. And so in this she leaves out the hands and the face. And this is that she would cover her her head and the covering of the head. It's important how she mentions it. It's covering the head that would come down over the shoulders. What does that mean? A lot of times the we see a kind of modern hijab where it's kind of pushed into the clothing. The essence of the is that it it is placed on the head and comes down over the shoulders to cover this region and then a dress which covers the tops of the feet and leaves the hands. This is what mentions. Now this is according to the majority of the fukah of Islam including the three mahib of Im Malik and Ahmed Abu Hanifh he his medab was a little more lax in salah and that is that in his mab in salah meaning in private a woman does not have to cover the feet in salah in salah however in public which we mentioned there's a difference between the in public and many have learned this from the med of and assumed that this meant as well in public. No, the of is that the feet are not in salah only but in public they are according to the clear verses of and Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala mentions specifically covering the feet in public in the verse of He says,.
[Silence]
And so the scholars all agree that a woman in public must cover her feet. And the reason for this is that Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala specifically prohibited that a woman make sounds with her feet that would articulate by way of sound what she is wearing on her feet. You might say, "What does that mean?" Well, if you can see what she's wearing on her feet, she doesn't have to use sound to articulate that correctly. It's visual. It's it's visible. So, the scholars, they understood this from this verse in so they've all agreed that the feet in public is the only difference is in salah. The majority is that the feat is in the of it is not but we've also heard the narration of when she was asked about this topic and she mentions that the tops of the feet should be covered as a minimum in salah for the woman making salah when she was asked this question. And this is the dress that a person must have when making around the cabba. Because remember the verse that we open this chapter with was regarding the making around thea in an indecent way. Remember? So this is the bare minimum for around the ka and when he was asked specifically about a woman's clothing he specifically said she must cover her feet inf meaning it becomes more strict in because it's a public setting and so when a person is inf remember we said that a person makes wudoo for three activities in Islam. Correct? Meaning you must have woo for these three activities in Islam. Number one, salah. Number two, handling the Quran, the mus. Number three, making because is considered a type of salah. And a person must cover his in as he would in salah with the exception of the right shoulder in the first three trips around the Ka due to the narration in that to commemorate that time which we discussed yesterday. And then after three laps around a person covers his shoulders as per usual as per normal. The only difference between and salah are is is one difference one. What is that one difference? You are huh? Well, no. The one difference is you may speak in you can talk in salah. If you talk your salah is invalidated by talking, right? That's the only difference between and with respect to the with with respect to wudoo etc. person must have wudoo to make. If a person breaks his wudoo during he must go and make wudoo and come back. And the scholars differ. Does he pick up where he left off or does he start over? Inshallah, in the correct opinion, he picks up where he left off. As long as he doesn't, as the old-timers would say, as long as he doesn't lolly gag, as long as he doesn't go for lunch and then go shopping and then and then come back and finish up his person goes makes woo and comes directly back, they may pick up where they left off. So as a review the to simplify the of the man in salah is above the navl to include the navl to below the knee and it's equivalent on the back and sides and the shoulders the tops of the shoulders. All right. And for a female, all of the body except for the face and hands in. And keep in mind that the conditions of covering the this is to include that which is not tight to where it defines what's underneath. that which is transparent which you can see through. We said how do we gauge if something is considered transparent in Islamic law?
[Arabic recitation]
You can see the skin color. So if she Ali put on a t-shirt and Abdi put on a t-shirt, you could see his skin color, right? My skin color would just blend into the shirt, right? Z. So the point is is that you can see the skin color. Right? Now this differs from hijab. Hijab has eight pillars or eight conditions to it. Eight. The Quran and Sunnah does not tell the woman what she has to wear. Tells her what she cannot wear. Right? Because again, all of humanity has always been dressing themselves. Men as well, the Islamic law doesn't dictate you must wear this, you must wear a th you must wear an you must wear a not necessarily. what we are told is what we cannot wear, what is not going to be acceptable for covering the in public for men and for women. Many of these eight conditions are shared between men and women. Most of them only two or three are different between men and women and we will discuss those eight tomorrow inshallah. So tomorrow morning we will discuss the eight conditions of hijab and this applies to men as well except the parameters are different and there's a couple of differences with respect to the number of conditions. the number of conditions are more in the females responsibility towards covering thou than the males because of the delicacy of the exposure of the body in public for men and for women. So we'll discuss that tomorrow morning inshallah.
[Arabic recitation]