MCC Tucson Lectures
Muslim Community Center of Tucson
←This Week
October 11, 2026·Rabiʻ II 30, 1448 AH·7:45 PM·11m·Sunday-Isha

Why Allah Wants You to Repent

The Purpose of Repentance: Understanding Sin and Forgiveness in Islam

repentanceforgivenesshadithsinhuman natureIslamic ethicstawbahdivine mercy
▶ Watch on YouTube
✦

Summary

Sh. Ali Mashhour discusses a hadith from Sahih Muslim about the nature of sin and repentance in Islam. The hadith states that if believers did not commit sins and seek forgiveness, Allah would replace them with people who would sin and repent. Sh. Ali Mashhour explains the Islamic understanding of different types of sins: ism (matters of the heart), them (sins between a person and Allah), and say (sins involving others' rights). He emphasizes that repentance is central to human purpose and that making mistakes followed by genuine repentance is part of a well-rounded human existence, distinguishing human imperfection from divine perfection.

Transcript

Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.

Foram.

[Silence]

Muslim in the book of seeking forgiveness mentions here a narration on the authority of He narrates that the messenger of Allah sallallah.aii Wasam said, "I swear by the one whom my soul lies in his hand. If you all did not commit sins, then Allah would be would do away with you and he would create in yourstead a people that would sin and seek his forgiveness and he would then forgive them." This narration has been collected by im Muslim. So here in this narration the prophet Sam says there is a difference in the Quran in the sunnah between the word them and the word say and the wordim. All of these generally mean sin in general. But is usually mentioned in the Quran and Sunnah and it is regarding what happens in the heart when a person does something evil or when a person holds bad beliefs, when a person is jealous, when a person is hateful, when a person is spiteful, when a person refuses to do the right thing etc. fear. These things are referred to asim. And then in the Quran,.

[Silence]

So a them is usually mentioned and what's intended by a them is a sin that is between the person and Allah. It doesn't usually involve someone else, right? Person drinks alcohol. This is referred to as a them because this is between him and Allah. He didn't oppress or wrong someone else in the equation. The is usually used and refers to a sin that has to do with other people. All right? You sabotage someone. You steal their money. You take what's theirs. You backbite them. This is all referred to as what? Say so we have an imm with them was say alth is more for the hearts and them is between the person and Allah and a is a sin that has to do with other people's rights and for this reason in the hadith that I think most of us No, he says and follow up the with meaning that if you do something to another, do something good to that person in its place in order to make up for it. It's not enough to wrong others and just say, "Oh love, please forgive me." You're going to meet that person again. Even if it's the guy in the toll booth that you abused and drove on five states away never to see again, you'll see them again. This is the irony of our existence. The way that the disbeliever sees the world out of sight, out of mind. The believer knows that this world is extremely small and every person that you interact with, you will see them again. Every one of them. And the rights will be restored. Even if it is a fleeting moment, the rights will be restored and everyone will know his or her you know oppressor just as well as you know your own family members. So here in this narration the prophet sallall.aii Wasam says, "If you all did not and which word did he use them is the least of these things." He says, "If you all did not make mistakes, you did not sin, Allah would do away with you. He'd create a people in yourstead. They would then sin and seek his forgiveness and he would forgive them." Now, here's the question. Is Allah creating someone in our place to take our to to sin or is he creating them in our place so that they will repent? What's intended by this narration is not sin. What's intended is repentance. There are three dynamics that make up your relationship with Allah. Gratitude, patience, and repentance. All three of these have to be part of your in order to build a relationship with Allah. There has to be an element of patience, an element of gratitude, an element of repentance. If we didn't commit any mistakes, then we have no need to repent. And if we have no need to repent, Allah has no need for us because he wants a people to forgive. We are created for the purpose of Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala to bestow upon us grace, forgiveness, etc. This is the purpose of our existence. So we are not expected to be perfect. We are expected to be repentant. And so if a person is repentant, then this is exactly part of their part part of their well-rounded existence. Right? Repentance, making a mistake is a perfection in the human being, an imperfection in the creator. Could you imagine if we had someone imagine this? Imagine we had a person that never forgets anything ever, never never forgets a name, never forgets that you speak to them, they can repeat it a a recording device. Would we see this person as someone who is well-rounded or would we be kind of creeped out by this person? This is creepy, right? Because we would we would look at this as an imperfection because human beings have imperfections and their imperfections are part of their well-rounded existence contrary to Allah. It is improper, imperfect for Allah to forget, imperfect for Allah to make mistakes. That is his perfections. Our perfections are that we repent after making our mistakes. So what is the prophet saying here? He's saying you'll make mistakes. That's okay. It happens. Don't try to make mistakes. Try your hardest not to, but your nature will eventually seep through the cracks. Be ready. be at the ready to repent and know that this is why Allah created you so that you could repent. Don't try to don't don't look at your mistakes as if the it's the end of the war. You've lost everything. No. When you make a mistake, you pick yourself up. You dust yourself off. You ask Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala for forgiveness and you try again. That is part of the struggle. But if you are holding yourself to the you know to the to the if if you think that you're never going to make a mistake, this is this this person doesn't exist. Even prophets and messengers make mistakes. All human beings make mistakes. The point is is that we are to be at the ready with repentance at every time we make a mistake.

[Arabic recitation]