Why did the Prophet have four muezzins?
The Adhan in Islamic Practice: Historical Variations and Jurisprudential Preferences
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour discusses the historical and jurisprudential aspects of the Adhan (Islamic call to prayer) in Islamic tradition. He explains that the Prophet Muhammad had four muezzins across three locations (one in Mecca and two in Medina), each making the Adhan with slight variations that all constitute part of the Sunnah. Sh. Ali Mashhour clarifies that the different schools of Islamic jurisprudence (madhabs) chose different versions of the Adhan as their preferred practice, not because other versions were incorrect, but based on various criteria such as frequency of practice or regional preference. He emphasizes that scholarly differences should not be portrayed as right versus wrong, but rather as preferences within the framework of Sunnah. The lecture then transitions to discussing the dual Adhan system for Fajr prayer, explaining why two calls were established during the Prophet's time and how Abdullah ibn Umm Maktum, despite being blind, would make the second Adhan at the actual time of dawn.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
Alhamdulillah.
[Silence]
So we've mentioned previously that the prophet sallall.aii wasallam had how many? Four. In how many locations?
[Arabic recitation]
Mecca, one in two in Medina. in Mecca was Abu Mahad. His name is Ib. And in Medina was or Abdullahb and in was. Now he made his adan Bal and Abdah they made the same and for all we know the same Abu Mah was different that Adan was in Mecca this one was in Medina. Now the adan that most of us hear on a constant basis, the adan that we have here most of the time, this is the adan and of and subsequently and that is standard and half of it for with twice. Now Abu was more Abu was taught by the prophet sallall.aii Wasam to do something called a which is more a is what the author mentions in this section where he says and that is that he makes the beginning of the then just but when he gets to the he says them in a normal voice first all four of them and then he says them again in a loud adan voice and then the rest of the adan is the same. The is of Abu is the usually made by because that is the that the chose right where it's just the this is the of Now, what's interesting and the reason I bring all of this up, why is this important? Well, number one, it tells us that every version of the aden that you've or I have heard for that matter is the sunnah, right? Except for two versions. One is agreed upon as not part of the sunnah and that is the adan of the where instead of they say and instead of or along with Allah there will be things like etc things this this is agreed upon amongst the scholars of to not be part of the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam The other is a difference of opinion and that is making each by itself. Allahbar Allahbar Allahbar separate. This is something that the scholars differ on whether it is permissible or not but more or less agree that is not necessarily the sunnah because the four the four of the prophet Sam did not make the aden in that way. They made them in twos in those statements because they counted the statements. We discussed this before. Now, this is a a learning opportunity, right? And that is that now that we've learned that all of these different types of adan are part of the sunnah, which one is better, which one is more correct? Which one is preferred or preferable? Well, they're all part of the sunnah and they're all from the prophet sallall.aii wasallam. But that doesn't mean that one couldn't be preferred over the other for instance. And that goes back to where the mahib choose each of the im of the mib each author of each med. How they go about choosing from the vastness and variety of the sunnah which to adopt as their primary in their meth. And this is very important because the the the med they don't usually differ in issues this in a way where they conflict with each other. They say this is wrong and this is right. That's very rare. usually in the the four of of and even and often times in even the difference of opinion is this is preferred, this is better, this is more correct, this is right and they and they choose they make those choices based on different metrics whether it be this is what was made most more often, right? Or for instance, this is what was made in Medina, right? This was what was made by the majority of the things that. So, they choose one, but they're not necessarily saying the others are incorrect. Sometimes that happens, but that's rare. So now let's look at how the and this class is not on the mahib. This is this class is really on the sunnah of the prophet sallall.aii but it's a learning opportunity. We look at the four with respect to these adans these variet this variety of of and what do we see? Well, we see that and for the most part A chose and adopted officially for his MAB the adan of and the of right the He chose the opposite and they chose the of and the of right and the immed and of and the is a little bit different the he chose the of and the that is a little bit different. They do not repeat twice in his only said once and Allahbar only said once. But the point is is that they all draw from the same will. Where does the differing between the Mahib come from? We shouldn't even say the differing between the Mahib, the differing and the viciousness between some followers of the Mib that become extreme. And they say things that the imam of the Med himself didn't say such as this is right and that is wrong, that is wrong and this is right, etc. When the authors of these they did not say that all of these are part of the sunnah of the prophet. Now the next issue that the author mentions is the issue of Now what is that the person when he makes when the makes he says now the difference of opinion happens. Where is this said? This statement. Is it in the first ad then or is it in the second ad then? To understand this issue we have to go back to how adan was made in the prophet's time sam. And really why is there a second ad then? The reason there is a second aden is very similar to the reason why there's a second aden for Jumra which came later in the time of men. The reason for that is to aid people and to help people to wake up in the morning to get ready for and during Ramadan and during fasting and for those who are fasting for them to have a metric to know when to start their or when to at what point they are along in their how long is there going to be between now and the then because if you really imagine how it was in the time of the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam in Medina and that is that you could wake up at night and not really know what time of the night it is, right? You you couldn't really tell unless you were very in tuned with the environment. Unless you're able to go up on top of a a taller building to see the horizon in Medina, you could wake up, it could be 1:00 in the morning, it could be 5:30 in the morning, it could be 10 minutes from the adan, it could be 2 hours from the adan. So as a service, the prophet sallall.aii alaihi wasallam designated two for and that was and now what's interesting about this is that Maktum has a very prominent description anyone know what his very prominent description is he was blind so this is a very interesting choice in especially for our fud Right. So how is Abdullahbi Maktum making the adan for to understand this issue? We need to know that and they work together for one would make the adan before the break of dawn and one would make the adan at the break of dawn when it's time for at the break of dawn when it's time to stop eating. Bil made the first one. He made the adan that was we can call it a kind of gauge a warning adan that you know is eminent. That was his aden. Now he made the real or the true dawn aden the adan when a person must stop eating. The adan when a person may make fud the the actual time in the break of dawn. That was made by me. And the way he would make this is he would sit on top of the roof of the building that there was a building that was close to the masid that they would use to go up on top of to make the aden to be able to see the horizon and get the sound out. Right. and Bilal would make the first then Iban Omi Maktum would go up there and sit up there and as people are coming into the masid below him right he's on top of the building they're walking in and he would sit there and wait is blind until they would say some passerbys would say it's time for fud Fudg is in. Now then he would stand up and make the aden. This dynamic is very interesting because this means that he was being told to make the ad then when it was visible from the ground level not from up top. And this was acceptable. And not only acceptable but the prophet sallallah.aii Wasallam endorsed this and we will finish this inshallah tomorrow and be he was not just yet.