Where Can't You Pray? Three Forbidden Places
Places Where Prayer is Impermissible: Gravesites, Cemeteries, and Bathhouses
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour continues his discussion on the book of prayer, specifically addressing places where it is impermissible to pray. He explains that while the entire earth is permissible for prayer (unlike previous nations who were restricted to specific places), there are a few exceptions. Sh. Ali Mashhour discusses three prohibited locations: gravesites and cemeteries (based on hadith from Jundab and others in Sahih Bukhari and Muslim where the Prophet forbade taking graves as places of worship), bathhouses (hammam), and emphasizes the importance of understanding classical Arabic terminology to avoid misinterpretation of religious rulings. He uses examples of how modern Arabic has changed the meaning of ancient words, potentially causing misunderstandings of prophetic traditions.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
Alhamdulillah. Continuing in the book of prayer regarding the chapters listing the places where it is impermissible for a person to pray. The places where it is impermissible for a person to pray. Now yesterday we discussed the framework for this and that is that where if I were to ask the question where is it permissible to pray everywhere except right it's kind of like Adam in paradise eat from anywhere you in this paradise except so there's a couple of dots right on the map that are impermissible but the essence of the earth is that it is all permissible and it is all pure and it is all purifying. There is no excuse a person may have who is conscious who's unable to pray. There's literally a an accommodation for prayer everywhere a person goes. In the previous nations, they had to pray in specific places. They had to pray in a church, in a synagogue, in a this ummah may pray everywhere. Alhamdulillah, except for a number of places. Those places can be counted on one hand. The first of those places we briefly touched on yesterday and that is where huh the graveyard or at any grave in general because when we say graveyard that could mean a place designated for graves. But what about if I find a place in the graveyard that doesn't have any graves in it? Is it permissible? The answer is no. It's still impermissible, which we will get to the evidence of that in a moment, inshallah. But it is impermissible to pray at a grave, any grave site, even if there is just a solitary grave there, it is impermissible to pray there. And we mentioned the narration of Jundab Abdah and many others of the companions in Bkari and Muslim 5 days before our prophet sallall.aii wasallam departed this earth and moved on to a much better place and a much better company. He uttered the words.
[Silence]
Abdah tells us that 5 days before our beloved prophet sallall.aii wasallam departed from this earth. He said indeed the previous nations, the people who you know the previous nations before you used to make a habit of taking the graves of their prophets and righteous as places of worship. Indeed, I I hereby prohibit you from doing so. Do not take the grave sites as messaged as places for salah for sujud as places of worship. He then mentions so this narration means anywhere where there's a grave, right? But then if a person's in a cemetery and there's a whole place that is completely free of graves, is it permissible to pray there? Here we have another narration also in a on the authority of who says he says all of the earth is a place of a masid. All right. And as we mentioned, these two narrations, they explain to us each other because a person could say, well, the previous narration that says do not take the grave sites as a masid. Well, that could mean just don't build a masid at a grave site. We say no, it's more broad than that. Do not pray at any grave site. How is that? Because Allah has made the entire earth as a what? As a masid. Correct. So this means that the entire earth has the ruling of a masid. Do you have to wake up in the morning and make masid in your bedroom? Of course not. What it means is that the entire earth is a place for salah. And that's what's intended here. Here in this narration, the messenger of Allah sallall.aii wasallam says, "All of the earth, all of the land is a masid except for the cemetery and the ham." The cemetery, a place that is designated for burial. This is a place that is impermissible to pray. So that's number two. Number three is Alam. This is a very good example of modern Arabic causing us to misunderstand ancient Arabic. And I'll give you an example here. The ancient words of Arabic, we still use them, but modern Arabic has given them new meanings. because of our culture, because of whatever. And so what ends up happening is if we take the current meanings of those words and apply them to the meanings of the prophet's words, this is where mistakes happen. Sai wasallam. So for instance, for those of us here who know Arabic, what is a m what is a mul? an actor, right? There's a narrations. The prophet sallall.aii wasallam says Allah has cursed the mum. Some have translated this to say Allah curses actors. That's not that's not at all what the narration is talking about. in the ancient Arabic is mutilating the dead on the battlefield. If you kill an enemy soldier to mutilate them, right? To carve them up to, you know, do things that people do with with dead bodies. He says Allah has cursed the mutilators. A m in ancient Arabic language is someone who mutilates a corpse. is not an actor. This is a modern meaning of a common word. Right? Another example. What is in modern Arabic? Does anyone know an atom? Yeah. They say physics is referred to as knowledge of which is plural for is an atom. But we have in the Quran a right. So if I explain that verse with the modern meaning, whoever does an Adam's weight of good will be rewarded accordingly. And whoever does an Adam's weight of bad will be punished accordingly. Is that what the verse says? No, it is not. A zra in the Arabic language is the tiniest tiniest tiniest ant. You know the little ants that are so tiny you can't even really see their legs. It just looks a dot moving around. That's a dra. And it is considered to be an analogy for something tiny in the Arabic language. Right? And so that is what the verse is speaking about. It has nothing to do with Adams, right? And here is another example. Alham what is a ham in modern Arabic? A bathroom, right? But that's not what the narration is talking about. I mean even our term bathroom is not what old English means bathroom. What is a bathroom? A bathroom is where baths are taken. A ham is taken from the root word alham. And it is where water would be heated and people would come and it's a bath house. People would go to bathe there, right? , you know, it's a modern-day sauna or if you've ever been to those Turkish baths for those bougie folks amongst us, may Allah, you know, keep you comfy and bougie. But those who have traveled, you know, you you go to those bathous where you go, you get a massage and you sit in the sauna and you're bathed with the very hot water. It's all steamy. It's a group place. That's what a ham is in the prophet's time sai wasam. It's a place where people congregate to bathe. It's a shower house. And this is what is meant by a hamm. We associate in modern English a bathroom with the bathroom that's in every house, right? Where that it has a toilet. It doesn't even have to have a bath in it to be a bathroom. It's a place where you go to relieve yourself. That's not a bathroom in the prophet's time. In modern Arabic, it means the same thing as a bathroom in modern English. But if we understand this, we understand that it is impermissible to pray in a sauna. It's impermissible to pro pray pray in a place a a public swimming pool. It's imper impermissible to pray in a bath house, right? Any place that where people congregate and have their clothing off in congregation. This is a place that prayer in it is invalid. prayer in it is invalid whether it has a toilet in it or not. Right? A toilet. This is this is a different ruling altogether. But when the prophet says that it is impermissible to pray in a mb a cemetery and a ham is a bath house and the scholars have defined this as a place where people go to bathe in congregation together. It's a public place or a private place but people gather there to you know bathe and for this reason there's ex extreme narrations regarding a ham. If we understood ham to be a bathroom there's narrations where the prophet sallall.aii wasallam says no woman who believes in Allah in the last day would ever go to a ham. Would we would we would we translate that to mean no woman who believes in Allah in the last day would ever go to the bathroom? This makes no sense, right? It's a ham. It's a congregational place where people take their clothes off and bathe or marinate or whatever it is that they do. So, these are three places that we've taken so far. a grave site, a cemetery and a bath house. These are three places where salah is invalid. If a person makes salah there, it's invalid. And we will mention the fourth tomorrow inshallah. be in a Muhammad.