Who Should Lead Your Prayer?
The Definition and Significance of Adhan in Islamic Jurisprudence
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour continues his discussion on the book of Salah, focusing on the definition and significance of the Adhan (the Islamic call to prayer). He explains that linguistically, Adhan means to announce something, and in Islamic jurisprudence, it is specifically the announcement made with particular words to indicate the time of prayer. Sh. Ali Mashhour discusses the narration of Malik, a young man who visited the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) and received instructions about prayer, including that one person should make the Adhan and the most knowledgeable in Quran should lead the prayer. The speaker emphasizes that the criteria for leading prayer are: the best reciter of Quran, then the most knowledgeable in Sunnah, then the earliest in Hijra, and finally the oldest in age—a principle he notes is often neglected in modern Muslim practice. Sh. Ali Mashhour also explains the historical significance of Adhan as a marker of Islamic identity, noting that the Prophet would observe whether villages made Adhan when deciding military strategy.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
Alhamdulillah. Continuing in the book of Salah in the chapters and subchapters regarding alan we mention in the Arabic language adan just linguistically speaking is to announce something. Allah subhanahu wa'ta'ala says in the story of Ysef that as they were leaving the city in Egypt and heading back to Hashem to their father with all of their camels heavy with grains and provisions. A muddin called out meaning that they started making Allahbarb. This means that linguistically speaking, an announcer announced very loudly, right? But in the legislation of Islam, what is the definition of adan? I mean, we all know what is, right? But in the later books of Phil scholars to give definitions to things because these definitions largely are what they base their rulings and understandings on. They say that in his book he defines to be the announcement. It is an announcement that is made with very particular words in order to articulate and announce the time of salah of any given salah. This is what Adan is. Then he mentions to us the narration of Malik. We said that Malik was a young man. He came to visit the prophet sallall.aii alaihi wasallam for a couple of weeks and then he went back home and he came at the very end of the prophet's life sallallahu alaihi wasallam in the ninth year after hijra or in the 10th year after hijra just before his death he taught them how to pray he taught them he taught them the you know basic tenants of Islam they got the opportunity to pray with him they got the opportunity to mix with the other companions and learn as as much as they could. And it wasn't just him. It was a a group of young men that came. But when he saw that they started to get homesick, he told them to go home. And he gave them these instructions with respect to salah. He said, he said, "If the time of salah is is upon you," meaning the time of when you are going to make salah because they're travelers. They're traveling home. He said, "Then let one of you make the adan and let the let the oldest or the eldest amongst you lead you in salah. Now notice here how he said let the eldest amongst you lead you in salah. The eldest an age. Now what does that mean? What do we understand from that is the oldest amongst us those more rightful to lead salah. The prophet sallallah.aii wasallam says in the narration of he says for.
[Silence]
He said the person who is to lead the prayer is the most well recited amongst a particular group. So if we're going to get together to pray, who does it leads us in salah? The one amongst us who is best recited. Best recited is different than most memorized, most versed. Best recited means memorized the most and recites the best and is generally most knowledgeable. And if they are all the same in the Quran, then the most knowledgeable of them in the Sunnah. And if they are the same in the Sunnah, then the earliest of them in Hijra. And in another wording outside of Sah Muslim and if they are the same in Hijra, then the oldest amongst them. These young men, they all came together. They're all the same in the Quran roughly. They're all the same in the Sunnah. They all saw what the others saw, right? They're all the same in their hij. And so for them, he said, the oldest amongst you is to lead for them. The general rule is the most knowledgeable in the Quran is the one who leads the salah. And we will get to those rulings when we get to the chapters regarding alim im the criteria of an im. And this is something that is so neglected now in general practice amongst the Muslim. As a matter of fact, people invite one another to lead the you would invite someone to sit down first, you know, or you would invite someone to you know, kick off their shoes first or something, you know. Go ahead. No, you go. you're going through a doorway. Yeah. Come on. know you you know like it's this is not how the the prayer would be set. the prayer should be said is the most recited, the most knowledgeable in the Quran, the most well-versed. That's the person that leads the salah. And this is a big responsibility even if it's only two people lead praying. He says, and so here we see that the prophet sallallah.aii alaihi wasallam commanded them to make a then even though they're not in a town he commanded them to make a then why because they're going to make salah and so any group of people they have to make a then because is we as we've mentioned and narrates that the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam this narration is in Bkari Muslim when he would plan to go to attack a town or a village, he would wait to see if this village made a then and he would wait usually until the morning till fud time. If they made the adan, he would leave them and move on to the next town. And if they did not, then he would consider them as non-Muslim. And this is part of a larger war effort during very particular years in the prophet sallallah.aii wasallam's campaigns which we will discuss when we get to the book of jihad inshallah the book of jihad which is maybe in about 30 years we will get there.
[Arabic recitation]