MCC Tucson Lectures
Muslim Community Center of Tucson
←This Week
November 12, 2026·Jumada II 2, 1448 AH·6:14 AM·13m·Thursday-Fajr

Must You Say Your Intention Before Prayer?

The Sixth Condition of Salah: Understanding the Intention (Niyyah) Without Misconception

intentionniyyahsalah conditionsislamic jurisprudencefiqhprayermisconceptionsmadhabs
▶ Watch on YouTube
✦

Summary

Sh. Ali Mashhour continues his detailed analysis of the conditions of salah using the book Al-Wajeez. In this session, he addresses the sixth and final condition discussed by the author: intention (niyyah). Sh. Ali Mashhour clarifies a widespread misconception that Muslims must verbally pronounce their intention before prayer. He explains that intention is a natural, internal act of the heart that occurs before any action, and that verbalizing it is neither required nor supported by Islamic scholarship. He demonstrates the logical absurdity of pronouncing intentions and notes that none of the four major Islamic schools (madhabs) require this practice, nor did the Prophet Muhammad or his companions ever do so.

Transcript

Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.

Alhamdulillah.

[Silence]

Continuing in Alwaji in the book of prayer and we have thus reached the final listed condition of salah that the author has mentioned. The author has so far mentioned and we've discussed five. Today's will be six. However, there are actually nine. When we really really look hard at many of the principles and evidences, we'll come to see that there are nine conditions of salah. These here these six are the most necessary for us to know individually collectively so that our prayer is accepted. The remaining three are more of a technicality but I will mention them inshallah so as to have a full picture. The final condition that the author mentions here, condition number six, he says ania person must have an intention. Person must have an intention. I think this is pretty known to all of us. The prophet sallall.aii says Deeds are rewarded and judged based on the intentions behind them. And a person will only receive reward for his actions and deeds based on the veracity of his or her intention. And so the intention here is a very important point. But however, it is also one that is grossly misunderstood by many people and it turns into a source of a source of was source of whisper from a shan for many people with respect to the condition of intention. Now intention obviously is necessary for any deed to be acceptable. Most deeds 99% there are a few exceptions but salah is not one of them. However, intention resides in the heart. It's never reside in the in the tongue. It is never something that is written down. It's never something that is spoken. A person does not speak his intentions. An intention is something that occurs just before an action and it is the reason behind the existence of said action. That is why it is a condition of salah. Now people naturally have this. It's not something that you need to go out of your way to learn how to do to learn how to make an intention. Human beings naturally we make intentions when we go to do everything and announcing set intention is not part of the intention itself. As a matter of fact, imagine if I had to say my intention for salah, right? So I say, okay, I have intended to pray. Well, I need an intention to make that intention and to say that intention. So I could also say the intention to say the intention, right? But then that would need an intention as well, right? Because in order for any statement that is worship of Allah to be valid, it has to have an intention. So if I say my intention for saying my intention, we see where this starts to become absurd. Correct? And the issue is is that later jurists, latter jurists around after around and after the fourth to fifth century of Islam, they started to focus in on refining books and perfecting their writings. and they wanted to make sure that they touched on all issues that needed to be spoken about and intention became a very big obsession in research. However, some of the later Fukahhata started to say things like, "You don't have to say your intention, but it's good to say your intention because the tongue helps the heart." And this in itself is incorrect. It's the other way around. And second of all, all of the fulkah agree that if your intention truly contradicts what you say, then your intention is what the action is judged on. What do I mean by that? So let's say a person comes to make and they go through their whole statement of intention. When I was a kid growing up, we were taught a very specific way to say your intention, right? I have intended to pray two for behind this im. I mean in case anybody was mistaken behind this im facing the right now what happens if absent-mindedly instead of saying I accidentally say imagine I'm here to make I stand to make my salah I say my intention and instead of saying two for which is what I intend I say four slip of the tongue absent-mindedness right and then I make my salah is my salah valid or invalid so what's the point of saying it then there is no point zero point there is no point to saying it there's no evidence for it first of all this is the most important And contrary to popular belief, none of the four imams of the major madib have ever said a person is to pronounce his intention especially for none of their writings and none of their students have authentically narrated that it was the position of any one of the four imams Abu Hanifh Malik and Ahmed and even the other such as the such as orb and or the scholars of of the the school of thought of hadith. None of them have even suggested that a person is to say his intention because of this reason and many others. method. And so the point of intention is that a person intend the act of worship and define that act from other acts of worship. So when he stands to make salah, he is defining two things. Number one, what he's doing and number two, his intention defines whether this is the obligatory prayer or the sunnah salah or what have you. but never to speak it. Because as soon as a person looked at his watch to see what time it was because he's planning to go to the masjid, he already made his intention. As soon as a person put his shoes on to leave, he already made his intention. As soon as the person got into his car and drove here and came into the masid, he's already made his intention. As soon as the person makes wuloo, they've already made intention for salah. Right? And so to say the intention would at best be redundant and at worst be unnecessary. for.

[Silence]

Young.

[Silence]

So what's interesting is that not only have the companions never narrated that the prophet sallall.aii alaihi wasallam ever said his intention, whispered his intention, taught others or instructed others. Not only is there no authentic narration, there's no narration at all. Not even a fabricated narration exists with this meaning. There's not an authentic narration. There's not an acceptable narration. There's not a weak narration. There's not a fabricated narration. There's not even whispers. There's no narrations from the companions which is very bizarre because imagine how many times the prophet sallallah.aii wasallam prayed. How many times did his companions pray? Not one person, not even with a weak chain of narration. This means that they all agreed to not do this. And the understood that and the four imams understood that. We will continue this tomorrow.