Why Your Ameen Might Be Wrong
The Proper Form of Prayer: Opening Duas, Surah Al-Fatihah Recitation, and the Correct Timing of Ameen
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour provides detailed instruction on the proper form and etiquette of prayer (salah), specifically focusing on the opening supplications (duas) and the recitation of Surah Al-Fatihah. He explains that duas at specific positions in prayer must be based on the Prophet's example rather than personal innovation, and discusses how the Prophet would recite the opening dua silently most of the time while beginning Surah Al-Fatihah audibly. Sh. Ali Mashhour emphasizes the correct timing and manner of saying "Ameen" after the imam completes Surah Al-Fatihah, highlighting common mistakes such as starting before the imam, saying it silently in congregational prayer, or continuing after others have finished. He concludes by explaining that the purpose of unified congregation prayer is to synchronize faith and create harmony, using the analogy of dominoes to illustrate how individual discord disrupts the collective spiritual benefit.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
It's like.
[Silence]
Alhamdulillah.
[Silence]
Continuing in the description of our prophet sallall.aii am how he used to make prayer the form he would use at each and every junction movement and statement. we had mentioned yesterday a couple of introductory principles a a couple of introductory u things. Number one that he would make this dua just before opening after before making he would make these specific. Now, one thing that's important for us to note, can a person make any dua that he wants at this junction or does it have to be something from the prophet sallall.aii wasallam? The answer is it has to be from the prophet sallall.aii wasallam by his word. Why is that? Well, for a number of reasons, but one of the most important reasons is that this particular position is for recitation. That's what it is for. If a person is to add to that position, they must have some kind of evidence to add to that position. And so, we have evidence that he would make a particular dua or two or five or seven. there are roughly about seven and not anything else. And we don't have any evidence that the companions would make up their own ada or that he invited them to make dua at whatever comes to mind in this junction as he did in sujud as he did in sitting position after tut. Right? Those are positions in which he invited people to make dua with whatever comes to mind. He would then say one time at the very beginning of his prayer before the first recitation of fat and then he would not say it again. He would then say the author here says and he would not say it audibly. He wouldn't say it aloud. He wouldn't recite it as he would the rest of his recitation. He would say it to himself, right? And that is most of the time, probably 85 or 90% of the time, he would say it to himself. There are evidences very few authentic evidences that state that the prophet sallall.aii wasallam would reciteman audibly but these are very few. Then we have other narrations that articulate that he never recited aloud. So, how do we harmonize those? Well, we harmonize those. Instead of saying he never did it or instead of saying he did it all the time, we harmonize those as most of the time, the overwhelming amount of time, he would not recite aloud. However, on occasion, he would start with recited aloud. On occasional says, and Muslim, I prayed Malik, the prophet's servant saiam served him for 10 years. He said, I prayed behind the prophet sallall.aii alaihi wasallam and Abu Bakr and Omar and none of them would begin their recitation withman nor would they end their recitation with it and they would all start with alhamdulill so we understand from this that the overwhelming majority of the time he would not recite it aloud sometimes he would sometimes he says says and then he would proceed to recite and in the audible prayers he this would be the beginning of what the people behind him are hearing now right everything is to himself until he arrives at alhamdulillah this now is the first thing that they hear from Alhamdulillah. He would begin with that and he would then proceed to recite and he would recite it one verse at a time. He would recite it one verse at a time. Meaning that he would stop at the end of each verse rather than running it all together. He would stop at the end of each verse. And this is this this would mean that he would pause at roughly six times during his recitation of surah fat it's seven verses we would pause six times at the end of each verse he says and when he would complete reciting surah fat. He would then proceed to say audibly and he would extend it. He would elongate it. Right? And this is where a lot of mistakes occur. Do we have evidence that the prophet sallallah.aii would say with the people. Yes, we do. And ink the im narrates that the companions made it their tradition after to say all together in one harmonious voice to the point where the masid would shudder. And that's the point. Many mistakes happen when it comes to am first of all means. Oh Allah answer this dua. The mistakes that occur are number one people begin to say it before the im. This is a mistake. When the imam completes and says people immediately start saying usually the imam has to take a breath. He has to take a breath and then he begins saying amen. The sunnah is to say a to start with the im and end with the im. And when we say start with the im meaning right after he begins as soon as you hear the imam's voice saying am then you say am with him. The second mistake is that sometimes people don't say it at all or they say it to themselves in an audible prayer or they will often lag way behind the imam to where the imam will conclude saying a mean and then they will say am. This is also another mistake less common than the first but still prevalent. Another mistake is starting am whether it be with the imam or after the imam or before the imam and then ending without the imam. And this happens sometimes with fancy guys. What do we mean by fancy guys? guys that just want to be different. All right. So, everybody in the masid is saying in one voice and this guy he's I mean, right? Or everybody's done and he's still going. A mean or people starting at different times a chorus it's a it's a a fifth symphony, right? This all of this is incorrect. The point of prayer together is synergizing our faith that Allah will accept. If he doesn't accept from one or two or three of us, all three of us together, he will accept. That's number one. Number two is harmony. That's the whole point. Harmony meaning that even if one person is slightly ahead of another person in the row, harmony is lost. Have you ever seen a stack of dominoes? Or have you ever seen a string or a chain that is all one continuous line? If there is a bend in that, if there is something out of place, what happens? It affects everything and it throws the harmonics off of all of it. This is the point. And that's what the prophet sallall.aii wasallam tells us and we will pick this up again tomorrow inshallah. forham.