Should Adhan Follow the Clock or the Prayer?
The Timing of Adhan: Catering to Prayer Time or Prayer Performance
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour continues his discussion on the rulings of Adhan in the book of Salah. He explains the two primary functions of Adhan: informing people of the time for prayer and announcing when Salah is about to be performed. Sh. Ali Mashhour clarifies that when these two functions conflict—such as when the time for prayer comes in early but Salah will be performed much later—the Adhan should primarily cater to the Salah rather than the time of prayer. He illustrates this principle with examples from the Prophet's practices during travel, where the Adhan was made around the time of actual prayer performance rather than strictly at the beginning of prayer time. Sh. Ali Mashhour emphasizes that while ideally both functions should be served simultaneously, the primary purpose of Adhan is to signal the upcoming Salah gathering.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
Alhamdulillah. Continuing in the book of Salah in the chapters regarding Alan. After having discussed the wordings of alen and the wordings of al. Now we go into some of the details regarding the rulings of So the conclusion that the author puts here is that it is preferred that adan be made at the start of its time meaning as soon as the time for comes in and that it be at the beginning of its time especially for now we discussed this before and that is where does adan belong is the adan to be made at the beginning of at the beginning of the time regardless and irrespective of when the prayer is going to be made or is the aden follow the prayer which means the aden is going to be made around the time of salah to cater to salah. So we have two issues here either the adan is being used because what is the adan for? It's for two things namely number one it's to cater to the time of salah to tell everybody that the time of salah has come in the time of day it's it's the first function of the adan the second function of the adan is to cater to the salah to inform of when the salah is going to take place now if those two things are not the same. Meaning either the salah is not going to be made at that time and now we have to choose one. Does the adan and should the adan cater to the time or should the adan cater to the the nature of is that it belongs and is to function to cater to salah All right. So for instance, here in this masjid, we have very few neighbors of the masid that are Muslim. Most of the people in the neighborhood are not Muslim. And even those who are Muslim, they are not dependent on the adan for the time. People go by their watches. They go by the time charts and we put out a time chart every month that tells people when the time of salah comes in, when the is etc. So being that that is the case, let's say is being made at 7:30 and comes in at 6:55. Should the ad then be made at 6:55 35 minutes before and no matter how far away the time of is from adan it should always be made at the time when the salah comes in or should the aden cater to the salah? The answer is under these circumstances the caters to the and even outside of those circumstances and so when we have to choose between one of those two functions whether catering to the time or catering to the salah it always caters to the salah because adan is primarily to cater to the salah. So if we were to say back at our example is at 7:30 but it comes in at 6:55 or 6:50. When should the adan be made? Preferably the adan would be made about 10 minutes or so before the salah. It should be made before the time for the prayer in Jama. Now you may say where did we get this from? How do we understand this? Well, we know that when the prophet sallall.aii wasallam would travel. Now we see the function of the aden because the aden really now is either going to because they wouldn't travel and make salah at exactly the time that the salah is in every single time. That's not how travel works, right? they are more forced to make camp when travel allows them to rather than when the time of salah is in. And so when would the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam make? The answer is he would have the adan made around the time of salah. He would have the adan made at the time of salah. So as they're traveling, the time of salah may come in. Now he's looking for a place that is ideal for camping. One or two 10 20 30 minutes go by, 40 minutes go by, they find the ideal place. He will halt the caravan and then he will command the make the adan. But the adan is made when when it is time for salah, not when the time for salah is necessarily in. And from this and all other re many other narrations and instances, we understand that the primary function of adan is to cater to salah more so than to cater to the timings of salah. However, if we are in a situation where those two things can be had simultaneously, then that is fine. The best time is to make the at the start of its time.
[Silence]
He says Samur narrates that in the time of the prophet sallall.aii wasallam in Medina Bil would make the adan once the sun crossed its zenith and the time for was in. And he he said and came. And so would make the adan at the time when would first be in. And then he would not make the until the prophet sallall.aii wasallam emerged from his home. And once he emerged and he would see him would see him come out, then he would make the Now we know from before that the is something that fluctuated in the prophet's time because if it is very hot He said that when the sun would be particularly hot, delay making until it gets a little bit more tolerable outside. And so the prophet sallallah.aii wasallam practiced this. However, when did he have B make the adan? He had B make the adan at the start of time. But again, this is not as strong of an evidence. Why? because everyone around in the neighborhood is Muslim and you have many people that are dependent on that more so than elsewhere and many people that are not going to be coming or do not have to come to Jama. You have people that are you have women, you have old people, you have sick people, you have all these people they are not coming to however they are still very dependent on that time of especially during those days when people didn't have watches and time charts and all of these things. So being that that is the case, this is how it was done at the prophet's time in Medina. But the dynamics was very different than our time here. But what we need to take away from this today, what we need to learn today is when the time of salah and the time of prayer. So when the time for a particular salah comes in the time and the prayer. So we have the time and we have the prayer. The adan ideally would cater to both. It would cater to both. However, if those are too distant for a then to cater to both, then it will cater to salah over catering to the time. This is how it was done in the prophet's time in Medina because of the circumstances.
[Arabic recitation]