Why You Can't Skip the Prerequisites of Islamic Knowledge
Understanding Authentic Hadith: The Importance of Scholarly Knowledge in Islamic Studies
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour concludes his discussion of the book of Istighfar (seeking forgiveness) from Riyadul Saliheen, noting this is the final narration before the author transitions to descriptions of paradise. Sh. Ali Mashhour emphasizes the importance of properly understanding hadith narrations, particularly those from Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, which are the foundational pillars of the Sunnah. He addresses how some Muslims attempt to dismiss or minimize narrations they don't immediately understand, using the analogy of learning mathematics before ballistics or anatomy before medicine to explain that Islamic knowledge requires foundational prerequisites and scholarly guidance. Sh. Ali Mashhour warns against self-interpretation without proper training, explaining that brushing aside authentic narrations actually undermines Islamic foundations rather than protects them.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
Alhamdulillah.
[Silence]
We are at the last narration in this chapter of the book of Alar. So it's the 19th book of Riald. essentially is a collection of 19 books and this book is the book of and we went into through the first chapter of the book of this chapter which is the chapter regarding the virtues. the merits of seeking forgiveness, of seeking pardon from Allah and also the various commands that Allah has given with respect to and we have journeyed through this chapter. We have learned a number of new types of a number of new ways to seek. we've discovered and contemplated on the meanings of al and the implications of alistar on the soul. And now we are in the last narration of this book, the last narration of this chapter, excuse me. After this, the author will go into the descriptions of paradise. And the reason for that is that what is the ultimate goal of it is to escape hell and to be admitted into paradise and ultimately to be the recipient the constant eternal recipient of Allah's mercy. This is the point of our lives. This is what matters. And this is the center thrust of. Now, we have a narration here that I'm going to go ahead and read. I'm not going to skip this narration. And the reason I'm going to read this narration is because this narration and others it have been woefully misunderstood. Woefully misunderstood. And because of that understanding, many have attempted to brush it off and discredit this narration, thinking that by doing so, they are protecting the prophet's sunnah when in reality they are chipping away at the foundations of our religion and the foundations of the prophet sallall.aii wasallam's sunnah. the two books that are the centerpiece, the true pillars of the Sunnah that we have to this day that have preserved the sunnah and all other books and works of hadith circle around these two books. What are these two books? Bkari and Muslim. As a matter of fact, Bkari is the centermost. Muslim revolves around and expounds upon Bkari. And these two books contain the essence of the prophet Sunnah S. These are not these books are just as off limits as the Quran itself. They are just as off limits as the Quran itself. We never say or attribute or discredit anything in these books that our scholars have not discussed or spoken of. And just sweeping something under the rug does not help anything. It doesn't help anything. I'll give you an example. For instance, non-Muslims, people who have an axe to grind with Islam, people who decided that Muhammad was not a prophet sallallah.aii wasallam before they ever heard his words or read his story. People who decided the Quran is not the words of Allah before they even read it. people who have decided to disbelieve before they have even received the evidences of belief. These people will say anything. This is the human being's nature. The human being likes to argue. And so sometimes the enemies of Islam, the enemies of the Quran, the enemies of the Sunnah, they cherrypick ambiguous narrations or verses from the Quran as an evidence to bolster their disbelief, right? We see this all the time. Who deals with this? Who is responsible for for defending Islam from these things? It is the scholars of Islam. It is not the general person. And a person may say as a Muslim, just a regular Muslim, well now this is something that I'm doubtful of. How do we fix it? I need an answer right now. Not all knowledge works that way. You know what that's like? That's saying I want to understand ballistics without studying calculus. No calculus, no algebra and I do not want to study mathematics at all but I want to know about ballistics. How can that happen? How is that possible? I refuse to study geometry, but I want to know the ins and outs and intricacies of the way that buildings are engineered, the way that shapes work, the way that architecture is built. That's not how knowledge works. You will knock on that door until you turn blue in the face. You will never learn it. You have to go through the steps. You have to earn that knowledge. And this is why the scholars of Islam work very hard throughout these centuries to take these big books, right? Like Muslim and to summarize them, to make them to make them accessible to the average Muslim this book right here. What is this book? but an amalgamation of the most authentic and known narrations of the prophet sallall.aii wasallam that are relevant to every Muslim and Muslim. That's what the purpose of this book is. You say, "Well, I want to go straight to the source. I want to crack open and start put my feet up, you know, and start reading." That's not how it works. You don't get to access that door that. You have to go through the channels. You want to learn about ballistics, you need to learn calculus. You want to learn about architecture, you need to learn geometry. That's just how it works, right? You want to learn about you want to learn about medicine, you have to study anatomy. It's just how it works. That is a prerequisite to understand. And so when these narrations come out and you know we see these shuet displayed to us, we want to have an an answer that is exactly the way that we expect it to be to be convincing to us at the moment. But that's saying, I want you to take this steak and I want you to make it accessible to my two-week old child. I want him to eat this steak. So, I need you to make this steak so I can feed it to my son. That's not how it works. Adult food is poison to little children. Now, having given that introduction, I'll give an example about for instance what I'm speaking about. And alkari the prophet sallallah.aii Wasam was narrated authentically to have married at a young age at 6 years old. This is when the marriage contract was made and the consummation of the marriage a few years later. Now person may come and say hold up a second this is you know how can we understand there's no way this is authentic that's not how narrations are authenticated or dismissed it doesn't work that and if you open the door to start ticking away narrations sunnen that you don't understand at the moment of reading them at that junction you are at in your life and in your knowledge you will actually end up sabotaging your own religion in the in the attempt to try to save it. And the scholars give an example. They say, for instance, there was a man who had a friend. It was a bear. He had a friend that was a bear. This bear loved this guy. This bear loved this guy. Right? This is an Arab idiom. He loved this guy. And when this guy would go to sleep, the bear would sit there and watch over him while he's sleeping. He loved the guy so much. So one day, the guy took a nap and his friend, the bear, sat over him as per usual, watching his best friend as he slept. And then what happened? A fly came and landed on his friend's nose. And he was very worried about his friend. No one touches or disrespects my friend. So the bear being what he is and being his nature, he grabbed the nearest boulder and he smashed the boulder down on his friend's head. He smashed his friend's head into a million pieces and the fly flew away to find its next landing place. This is exactly the example of a person who is unequipped to deal with something how they will react to the slightest of advances on something that they love. It's understandable for us to want to defend Islam, but we don't speak for Islam unless we are authorized. And so when there is something, we ask the people of knowledge. And when the people of knowledge give us a response, maybe we don't understand it because we're not ready to understand it. We say and we move on with our life. You are not owed an answer to every little in and out regarding every narration and verse of the pro prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam or verse of the Quran. And that's normal. We all go through that, right? That's part of learning. We all go through that that place where we don't understand something and we wish we could understand it at the moment. But if you really want to understand it, you would go through the steps to earn it. It's not just I don't want to learn calculus, but I do want to learn ballistics. I don't want to learn I don't want to learn anatomy, but I do want to learn medicine. So make those two work. It doesn't work that way. It just can't. Knowledge has to be earned and it has stages to it. So we will mention this narration tomorrow. Big big you know introduction and what do we call it? big preface to this narration. We never got around to reading it. We've run out of time. We will read it tomorrow.
[Arabic recitation]