When the Adhan Calls, Stop Your Prayer
The Prohibition of Optional Prayers After the Call to Prayer
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour continues his discussion on the laws of prayer, specifically addressing the prohibition of optional prayers after the call to prayer has been announced. He explains that when the adhan is called, a person must immediately cease any optional prayer and join the obligatory congregation prayer. Sh. Ali Mashhour emphasizes that the majority of scholars agree that if someone has already begun an optional prayer when the adhan is called, they must break their prayer immediately to join the obligatory prayer, as this is the clearest interpretation of the prophetic narration. He refutes common misunderstandings, such as making taslim in the middle of prayer to exit or joining the congregational prayer late by waiting until the imam goes into ruku.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
Alhamdulillah. Continuing in the book of prayer regarding the times in which it is impermissible to pray optional prayers. The author now mentions a time that is specific when it is prohibited to pray an optional prayer and that is as the author says. It is likewise prohibited to pray optional prayers after the prayer has been announced. the for the obligatory prayer has been announced. So a person's in the masid and the is called. Now it is obligatory for a person to join the prayer. There is no optional prayer during that time. And this is exactly what the narration says. He says on the authority of Abi who narrates that the prophet Sam if the prayer has been announced and established the has been called then there is no valid prayer except for the option prayer. He says in the footnote. He then mentions what a very large amount of scholars and and jurists mention and that is that the question now becomes if a person has already started the optional prayer when the is called what shall he do? The majority of the scholars are of the opinion that if he is unable to finish his optional prayer before and the obligatory prayer, then he is to break his prayer and enter with the J. And another opinion of the scholars of the fukah is that based on the clear the clarity of the narration and the straightforward nature of the narration he says which which translates to no optional prayer is valid no prayer is valid after the is called except for the obligatory one. This means that a person is to break his prayer immediately and join the jama and this is the stronger of the two opinions. If a person is in salah sunnah, you know, in a optional prayer, any optional prayer and the is called, he is to break his prayer and enter into the obligatory prayer immediately. And the only prayer that is exempt from this is an obligatory prayer, right? Because the wording of the narration if the is called then there is no valid prayer except for the obligatory one. If a person is in an obligatory prayer let's say he's traveling and he's joining prayers. He's praying for rights to finish that prayer and then join because it's an obligatory prayer. He's doing what the narration is commanded. And this honestly is the stronger opinion because we do not find any narrations where the prophet sallall.aii Wasam and the companions are praying in the masjid and there's other people making salah not with the just it was not a sight that you would see and so the companions understood that as soon as the is called all other prayers cease except for the obligatory one. Have you ever Well, you have. I'm positive you have. But you come to the masid and when people walk into the masid, the most likely place if they're waiting for salah for them to make their sunnah salah is going to be where? In the front row, right? Right here in this row. Then the is called. They look at the clock. They see there's only 20 30 seconds left. They Allahbar and now they're praying right there. Everybody is trying to make the row for the salah, but he's praying. So, we can't walk before him or behind him or to the right or to the left and he's just there and we all have to wait for this person to finish his salah. This never happened in the prophet's time saiam ever. Ever. Because when the is called it is a it is an indicator that everything else stops. Now how does a person stop his prayer? A lot of times you'll see people that make and they're standing. They wish to leave that optional prayer. they'll they'll make sleep. And you see this a lot with people also that forget to make wudoo or break their wudoo during salah. They leave the salah by making. There is no narration that you will ever find anywhere ever that the prophet sallall.aii alaihi wasallam made in any other position except for the sitting position after or in salah janaza in the janaza prayer. Yes, you make while you're standing. That's the only in instance an exception. It would be no different than a person reciting fatud. It would be no different than making sujud before aur. It would be no different than sitting in the standing position or standing in the sitting position. Tim's place is after in order to end the prayer at its point. If a person leaves the prayer before that point, they just leave. That's it. There's no and this is something common you'll find. There is no clear evidence for this. And so if a person is praying and they must leave the salah for some reason, they just leave. And immediately upon intending to leave the prayer, your prayer is broken. Anyways, the mere intention to leave the prayer already ends the prayer without a person doing any of this other fancy, right? And I say this is it had not it had from the scholars it had from the common man right how many of us have seen this before right we've seen this a lot maybe even we do it but if you think back where did I get this from well we saw other other people doing it and we assumed that that was the correct way to do it right and So if a person is in salah and the is called in the correct opinion they are to leave the prayer immediately and join the salah and at most the scholars agree that it's not permissible to continue praying the optional prayer and miss this rur of the obligatory prayer. So we have two instances. A person leaves immediately upon the is call. This is the correct opinion. Second, a person stays in salah to finish but he can finish before. This is the absolute most than any scholar has mentioned. Number three, a person finishes his optional prayer even if he misses one or two raqa of the obligatory prayer. The scholars have all agreed this is incorrect. We understand these three scenarios. And if if you were to hear this statement of the prophet Sam If the prayer the has been called then there is no prayer except for the obligatory one. What would you understand from that? Would you understand from that to keep praying as long as you don't miss? because this is using evidences from elsewhere that don't belong there. This is why we mentioned that the apparent face value of the narration is leave salah. You leave it because the prayer is no longer is no longer necessary. Is it obligatory for a person to be in salah? And this brings us to an important point. A point that is very very commonly misunderstood. How many of us have seen or ourselves have done that the salah is going on and we let's say are on a phone call or sitting and waiting and you see this a lot during in Ramadan that a person will sit and watch the prayer until the imam goes into and then they join. Do you know what I'm talking about? Have we seen this before? You see this a lot. Why do I say and tell her we cuz people get a little tired, right? So they will sit and watch the prayer and listen to the recitation and watch the imam until he reaches. Then they get up and join the prayer. It's kind of a a hack, right? a a cheat code, right? The scholars agree this salah is invalid. The scholars agree this salah is invalid. Why? Because the prophet Sam said he said whoever catches the of a prayer has caught the prayer. Correct. This narration does not apply to someone who purposely avoids praying part of the prayer. This narration is speaking to someone who's late, something that is out of his control. He's making woo. He's on his way to the masid and despite his best efforts, he's missed a portion of the beginning of the prayer. But those parts that you deliberately missed in salah, the recitation of fat, standing for the recitation of al fat and elsewhere, saying Allah abar to go into these are pillars and you cannot miss them purposely because a pillar by its very definition is that if a person misses it, the prayer is invalid. This is an invalid prayer and a lot of people do this invalidating their prayer not even knowing that they are doing this. If a person deliberately leaves off a portion of the salah with the im then this will nullify the person's prayer rather the a person may say well I'm tired during what shall I do join the prayer while you're sitting sit you will get half the reward for sitting that you will for standing and the optional prayer it's permissible to sit in In the standing part, you just receive half the reward. If you're tired, sit in the row and start your salah. Join the salah immediately. There's no instance in which you are supposed to be praying with the j and you're just sitting watching the j be made as as you breeze out in the corner waiting for your time to to jump in. You ever see the kids playing jump rope and they wait then they jump into the jump rope? This is this is not that situation. If you are joining the prayer you have to join as immediately as possible. And we will have an entire section in the book regarding this issue which we'll discuss later on inshallah.
[Silence]
What is.