Why Your Clothing Shouldn't Be a Tower
Conditions of Hijab and Proper Covering in Islam: Understanding Awrah and Tabarruj
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour continues his lecture on the conditions of salah (prayer), specifically focusing on the fourth condition regarding proper covering (awrah) during prayer and in public. He explains the fundamental Islamic principle that worship acts default to prohibition unless explicitly permitted, while customary matters default to permissibility unless prohibited. Sh. Ali Mashhour outlines the eight conditions of hijab for women in public, beginning with the first two: that clothing must cover the entire body except hands and face, and that the garment itself must not be an adornment that draws attention, explaining the Quranic term 'tabarruj' (display) through its etymological connection to 'burj' (tower), illustrating how clothing should not make one stand out like a tower among buildings.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
Alhamdulillah. Continuing.
[Silence]
In the conditions of salah, we have arrived with the author to the fourth listed condition here of salah which is and that is is that a person cover his or her which is a word used to describe that which is not to be revealed during salah. Now, as we mentioned before, the parameters of what is considered to be a what is considered to be inappropriate to reveal during salah for men and women is different than outside in public. We mentioned for men it is more strict in salah and for women it is less strict in salah. And so the general rule of that which a person must cover in salah and that which a person must cover in public is that they are essentially very very close. They are akin to each other but there are a few differences. Yesterday we discussed the parameters of a man's a and a woman's a man's a is that in salah he must cover between the navl to include the navl to below the knee or to include the knee along with his two shoulders. And for the female, it is to cover all of her body except for her hands and her face. Now, what about outside of the home or in general? What are the rules of what a person can or cannot wear? There are general rules which are shared between men and women. And then there are a few extra conditions for a woman. It's not very accurate for us to say what a man should wear or what a woman should wear. Rather Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala tells us what one mustn't wear what is prohibited because that is the nature of the legislation when it comes to customs clothing this is a customary thing all cultures have different clothes right and eating and drinking and sitting and walking and sleeping and speaking etc. Most of these things, these are customary things. These are not acts of worship in and of themselves. And so when it comes to customs, everything, the general rule is everything is permissible unless otherwise stated. And it is exactly the inverse of that. The exact opposite of that goes when it comes to worship. When it comes to worship, everything is prohibited except that which Allah has allowed. And so Allah gives permission for his servants, for his slaves to worship him. It is based on permission. And the opposite is true for customs. And so this is why the scholars tell this very very well-known principle and that is whatever the the the nature of acts of worship the the the default position of acts of worship is that they are all haram except with an evidence except that which is excluded. ed by explicit evidence from the Quran and Sunnah. And when it comes to customs, not acts of worship, everything is permissible except that which Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala or his messenger prohibit. It's very simple.
[Silence]
That when it comes to customs, everything is permissible until we have some evidence saying otherwise. And when it comes to acts of worship, everything is prohibited unless we have an evidence. So when we look at this from this lens, now we look at what the man and woman are expected to wear in public. You can wear any color, you can wear any style, you can wear any type of clothing etc. except that which is not prohibited and that which meets the following conditions. We can't quantify what you can wear. We can only quantify what you cannot wear. Right? When Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala put Adam and his wife into paradise, he didn't tell them where to eat. He gave them a general rule to eat and a specific prohibition. So he said, "Eat you and your wife from anything and anywhere except." And this is the nature of the Quran and Sunnah when it comes to customs. So the scholars have mentioned that there are eight conditions that a woman's clothing must meet for her to be in public with these with this clothing. When we say hijab, right, hijab, we use it as a general term to describe that which a woman wears in public. So when we say public, we mean outside of her husband and outside of her close family. That's public. So what can she wear or what should she wear? She can wear anything she likes as long as it meets these eight conditions. And a man can wear anything he likes as long as it meets most of these conditions, not all of them. So the scholars mention eight conditions of hijab. This is something very important for us to memorize, to commit to memory, to write down to you know to to consider when it comes to how we are seen in public. So eight conditions. Number one, the first condition and The first condition is that this garment cover all of the body in its entirety except for the two hands and the face. That's the first condition. And for a man it is that it cover between and to include his navl to below his knee. Now this is what is the bare minimum. But let's say let's say a guy walked in right now wearing nothing but a long pants that covered his navl to his knee. That is is that haram? No. Is it proper? No, it's improper. Right. So proper and improper that is an issue of place and time. However, haram andal this is what our current discussion is regarding. So the first condition is that it cover the entire body except for the face and the hands and for a man that it cover entirely what is between the navl and to include the navl to below the knee and to include the knee. Number two, the second condition and this is this is a condition that many fail to see, fail to realize. And that is that the garment that is to cover the entirety of the body except for the face and hands is not to be an adornment in itself. Right? It is not to be an adornment in itself. meaning it itself should not take the place of the attention a woman would would would draw with her body. Instead, she draws the same attention with her clothing. The clothing itself must be modest. It is not in itself a clothing that draws attention particularly, right? Because sometimes the clothing itself could be even better than the body underneath it, right? And if you realize that when a woman Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala in the Quran when he refers to a woman who dresses immodestly, not modest in public, this act of immodest clothing, what is this called in The Quran Allah says this act is called is a general word word in the Quran used to refer to a woman dressing indeently in public. Now, where does the word come from? It comes from the root word.
[Silence]
This draws from the same etmology and the same essence that the word comes from. Bourj. It's the same exact word. What is a bourge? A bourge is the tallest the tallest building in a city. This is referred to as a bourge, right? The tallest tower in the city in Arabic is referred to as a bourge. You know bourjifa? That's what it is. It's the tallest building. It is the tower of the city. And a is from that same root. The act of is drawn from the imagery of a woman using her body or clothing to stand out amongst the rest of people. Just as a building use a tower uses its height to be noticed amongst the rest of the skyline to set itself apart. So a in itself is the act of drawing attention by way of the clothing or the body or the way that she walks or speaks or what have you to draw indecent attention and set herself aside from the rest of people. Just as a tower uses its height to make itself obvious and a magnet to attention amongst the rest of the buildings in a city. This is what a taboo is. If you understand that this is why this word is used, you get a pretty good picture as to what is not permissible. Correct? You get a pretty good picture. And that goes for men and women because the prophet sallall.aii wasallam said the prophet sallall.aii alaihi wasallam said in Muslim Allah loves the servant who is contented who is righteous and who is very ordinary. He's hidden. He's not set aside from everybody else. He doesn't set himself aside by the way he dresses or the way he speaks or the way he walks or the way he talks or the clothing he wears or the No, he he he is not prone to exaggeration. He is one of the Muslim right. So being part of the collective and not necessarily remarkable in your in your presentation in public amongst your Muslim brothers and sisters. This is for men and women but it goes doubly for women because of the dangers of said behavior. So those are two conditions we took today. Number one, it must cover all that is from head to toe except for the hands and face. Number two, that it it is not a beautifification in itself. It doesn't draw attention. If she uncovered her body, it would draw attention. When she wears this clothing, it draws attention in the same way. So, it cannot take the place of that and drawing attention. And we will continue the next.
[Arabic recitation]
[Silence]
That's the exact word.
[Silence]
I don't know.