Why Can't You Pray Near Camels?
The Fourth Prohibited Place for Prayer: Camel Enclosures
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour discusses the fourth and final place where prayer is deemed invalid according to Islamic jurisprudence. He explains that prayer is prohibited in camel enclosures, contrasting this with the permissibility of prayer in pens of sheep and goats. Sh. Ali Mashhour elaborates on the reasoning behind this ruling, noting that while camels are halal animals with pure urine and droppings, their enclosures are nonetheless unsuitable for prayer due to the particular behavioral characteristics of camels (referred to as 'shamim') that negatively influence those around them. He completes his discussion by summarizing the four invalid places for prayer: gravesites, cemeteries, bathhouses, and camel enclosures.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
[Arabic recitation]
Bath house and or did we not mention it yet?
[Arabic recitation]
Just the bath house.
[Arabic recitation]
Thing we mentioned. Oh, well then I didn't tell you yet. Subhan Allah. I'm asking you to tell me something. I didn't tell you the fourth place. And this is something that is going to be extremely rare for any of us to ever have to practice. You never know, right? It's good to have this knowledge, but I doubt that any of us will find ourselves in this predicament anytime soon. for.
[Silence]
On the authority of Allah. He narrates that the messenger of Allah Sam was asked about a person performing salah in the living in the pen or the living area of camels. so you know how horses have a corral that they live in and chickens have a coupe and goats have a pen, right? Well, camels would have like a I don't know what it's called in English, but it's a it's kind of a pen where they live in, right? this is referred to as meaning in the places where the camels lay down, where they sleep, where they, you know, are kept when they're not out. And so he was asked about the permissibility of performing prayer in the camel's enclosure. And he said, "Do not pray in a camel's enclosure, for indeed it is of a shaim." Right? And then he was asked about the validity of performing prayer in the pen of sheep and goats. And he said it is permissible to pray in them. pray in them in their pens for indeed sheep and goats are baraka. Now this here is the fourth place that would make prayer invalid if a person were to make it there. If a person were to pray in the enclosure of camels and what's meant by the enclosure of camels is the place where they live, right? And this is unexpected because camels are permissible. They are halal and their urine and their droppings is not considered a type of nessa, right? It's considered to be they're considered to be pure creatures. However, where they reside and their enclosures, it's not permissible to prey in their enclosures. However, what about the enclosures of other animals that are permissible? Cows, sheep, goats, permissible. And the prophet sallallah.aii Wasam. He mentions regarding the first. What does that mean? That the camels are from doesn't mean that they are devils or they are evil. It just means that camels have particular behavior, sets of behavior that set them aside from the rest of domesticated animals and spending too much time with them will impact and impress upon a person. And as for the goats and sheep, the prophet sallallah.aii wasallam responded. He said, "Pray in those places for indeed they are baraka." Meaning that goats and sheep they are of they are blessed. And actually one of the only animals that we heard on earth, the sheep is actually one of the type of animals of paradise. The prophet sallall.aii alaihi wasallam mentioned that the sheep is one of the types of animals of paradise. And so this makes four four places where if a person prays in these places the prayer is what? Invalid. Now it doesn't mean that all other places are equal. There may be some places which are less conducive, less preferable for a person to make salah in them. But what's important is that as far as valid and invalid is concerned, it is four places. Number one, the grave site. Number two, the cemetery. Number three, the bath house. And number four, the pens and enclosures of camels. I learn a Muhammad.
[Arabic recitation]