How do scholars know where to pause in the Adhan?
The Structure and Variations of the Adhan: Medina and Mecca Traditions
Summary
Sh. Ali Mashhour continues his detailed analysis of the book of prayer, specifically focusing on the chapters regarding the Adhan (Islamic call to prayer). He discusses how scholars of hadith and Islamic jurisprudence have determined the exact structure and pauses of the Adhan by counting statements, tracing this methodology back to the time of the companions. Sh. Ali Mashhour explains the most common Adhan structure used in Medina (consisting of 12 phrases with specific pauses) and contrasts it with the Adhan of Abu Mahzura from Mecca, which includes a unique practice called 'tir' where certain portions are recited in a lower voice. He addresses scholarly differences of opinion regarding separating each statement of the Shahada and clarifies the distinction between what is permissible versus what constitutes the Sunnah practice.
Note: This transcript was generated using YouTube's automatic captioning, with AI-assisted cleanup for readability. It may contain inaccuracies due to background noise, audio quality, or limitations of the transcription software — particularly during Arabic recitation. Listener discretion is advised; please refer to the original video for precise wording.
Alhamdulillah. Continuing in the book of prayer in the chapters regarding Adan of Alwajis. Yesterday morning and the morning before we discussed the most prolific and common wording of the aden and not only that but we mentioned the exact sentences of alen and that is that the how do we know this? How do we know? I mean, if the words are all the same in books or in narrations, how do we know which sentences are are where where did the stop at the time of the prophet sallall.aii wasallam? So for instance the first four sentences of Allahbar Allahbar Allahbar Allahbar how do we know where the stopped and where the join the sentences because it's it's written in a book or it's narrated correct that is because the scholars of hadith and the scholars of and this goes all the way back to the time of the companions. They counted the statements and that is that they would count they would count Allahbar as one as two. So there are a certain number of sentences or a certain number of pauses, if you will, in and throughout the adan and the scholars have deemed the sunnah and others and other sentences or other phrases or pauses or other ways of coupling the sentences which are have been deemed by the scholars as inadequate or unacceptable. We mentioned before that the most common way and we say the most common way because as we said the prophet sallallah.aii wasallam had four muin four of the companions that were his dedicated muadin. He had two in Medina, one in Mecca, and one in Kobe. Now, the two in Medina that were with him, they have a way of doing the adan that they never changed. It was always this. And so, this is the most common. This is what was done in Medina. This is what both of these two did most of the time. Abu Mah was in Mecca his different and in Kub. Now we mentioned that the way that it was structured was the first phrase in adan. So that's one. Twice twice twice. Twice. So this is how many sentences or how many phrases or pauses if you will? 12. Okay. So count them as 12. Now in the it is exactly half of that except for the last two with the addition of twice.
[Silence]
And usually those are coupled together. How many is that? Eight. Eight. If we couple together in one in one without pausing between them that is the most common way and that is how anddah orb it's a difference of opinion on his name. This is how they made adan most usually most constantly. Bil made this adan during the conquest of Mecca when the prophet sallallah.aii wasallam had him stand on top of the Kaa to make adan on the day of al fat. This is the adan that he made. All right. This is the most common. Now we move over to the adan of Abu Mah. His kuna is Abu Mah and Abu Mahad does something that the others do not do and he learned this he was taught this directly by the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam and that is he does something called a tier and this is practiced still commonly in parts of North Africa in parts of Morocco Morocco, Tunisia, perhaps parts of Libya, perhaps parts of you know, Algeria. but this is not as common and many of us if not most of us have never heard this before. And is defined by the author So Abu he narrates that the prophet of Allah taught him the adan. He said he said to him say Allahbar Allah here it's missing two in your in your print there it has what what should be four okay so it's missing two it's oversight by the publisher okay Allahbarbar He says those in a normal voice just the voice I just said. So the adan begins as normal and then from a very loud voice he goes to a talking voice just this in this voice. Then he goes back to the and says it loud that. This is called a the rest of the adan is exactly the same. So how is this adan what is going to be different about this adan is that the shahada is going to be done eight times. two forahill two for Muhammad Allah four times it's going to be in a talking voice and that voice is defined by the scholars as being a voice that you could hear if you were close to the muin speaking distance and you would not hear if you were far away from the muin if you were at a distance from the muddin it would sound he stopped stopped for a little bit. Right? So the adan would be Allahbarbu.
[Silence]
And the rest of the adan is exactly the same as the adan of and the adan of now that is the main difference in adan between the two the two teachings. So one is in Mecca, one is in Medina. The adan is the same was the same as the adan of Bal and the adan of Abdullahbi Maktum. Now what is the ruling on separating each? So instead of Allahbarb it separate and pause between each of the four. So it'd be Allahbar Allahbar. This is a difference of opinion amongst the scholars. Many of them view this to be inadequate, unacceptable because this is not any practiced that the companions made in the prophet Sam's time. Whilst other scholars view this as being adequate but not necessarily the sunnah. Remember how we discussed before the difference between what is adequate and what is the sunnah. They're not necessarily the same thing, right? Not everything that is permissible is necessarily the sunnah. Correct? , and so this is kind of a person making wudoo and they separate between their mouth and their nose in mud. No narration mentions that the prophet sallall.aii wasallam ever made wudoo this. However, it is viewed as valid, permissible, not the sunnah, but it is permissible.
[Silence]
,.
[Silence]
And so you know he uses one of the evidences which is how the prophet sallall.aii alaihi wasallam taught us to repeat after the mu when he is making the aden which we'll get to inshallah but the point is is that the companions that counted the statements of adan and malik abdahbar and the narrations of the prophet sallallahi wasallam that outline the statements of the where the pauses are how many statements ments it is right there is no time when it is Allahbar Allahbar Allahbar that doesn't exist that's not the sunnah the sunnah is allahill the 12 statements that we mentioned before so today we took the adan of what is the ruling on the aden of can it be practiced? Should it be practiced? Yes, absolutely. The sunnah really is to practice each adan at least occasionally so that a person will have practiced all of the sunnah or as much as they can as possible. However, if a particular community or a particular masjid stuck with one adenan one way of making a den and didn't change it, that is better because that's what the prophet sallall.aii wasallam did right.